Laura Bogart
Mar 29, 2024
As Anthony DeLuca, CFP, CDFA and expert contributor at Annuity.org explained it, the wiser question isn’t so much how much money you can withdraw, but how much you should withdraw.
“The first step in understanding this is to build a detailed expense sheet. Understanding your needs and wants will lay the foundation and answer everything else,” he said.
The article discusses the complexities of managing a $3 million retirement fund, emphasizing the importance of careful planning and expert guidance.
Introducing the 4% Rule
The 4% rule is a traditional guideline suggesting retirees withdraw 4% of their retirement savings in the first year, adjusting for inflation annually. Ohan Kayikchyan, PhD, CFP, founder of Ohan The Money Doctor, explains, "you should withdraw 4% of total retirement savings the year you retire, adjusting the withdrawal amount annually to account for inflation." For instance, with $3 million saved, "you would start withdrawing $120,000 in the first year and adjust this amount for inflation thereafter."
Kayikchyan also suggests that to stretch your money, consider withdrawing less than 4%. He adds, "The reverse calculation is also helpful, as the same 4% rule is used to determine how much money you need to retire. Simply divide your desired annual retirement income by 4%."
Flexibility Beyond the Rule
Kayikchyan notes the 4% rule originated in the mid-90s with a portfolio split equally between stocks and bonds. However, the actual asset allocation and the length of one's retirement can differ, making rigid adherence to the rule potentially unsound, especially in high inflation. Elizabeth Pennington, CFP, points out that while the 4% rule offers a starting point, "Market context matters, and that’s where it’s worth consulting with a financial planner rather than relying solely on a rule of thumb."
Understanding Individual Needs
Taylor Kovar, CFP, emphasizes the importance of considering factors like life expectancy, desired lifestyle, expected investment returns, and other income sources when deciding on withdrawal rates. The goal is to balance one's desired retirement lifestyle with the need to preserve savings for future needs and unexpected expenses.
The Importance of Detailed Planning
Anthony DeLuca, CFP, CDFA, stresses the importance of determining not just how much money you can withdraw, but how much you should withdraw. He advises, "The first step in understanding this is to build a detailed expense sheet. Understanding your needs and wants will lay the foundation and answer everything else."
Tax Considerations
DeLuca also highlights the impact of taxes on retirement withdrawals. "If the assets are in a tax-deferred shell, then each withdrawal will be taxed at your income bracket." He warns that large withdrawals can push you into a higher tax bracket and recommends making sure any investments sold are for long-term capital gains, as these are taxed more favorably.
No One-Size-Fits-All Plan
Chris Urban, CFP, RICP, asserts that retirement income planning should be dynamic and ongoing. He suggests a "guardrails approach" that adjusts spending based on various factors, including age, income, investable assets, economic conditions, and legacy goals.
Conclusion
Given the complexities involved, retirees with substantial savings, such as $3 million, should consult trusted financial advisors and remain flexible with their retirement plans. As Urban advises, "Whether you are managing your finances on your own or with a qualified financial professional, it is important to revisit this several times per year."
Source: GoBankingRates - Laura Bogart